Scholars of the South Tigris: Honest & Precise Review

Scholars of the South Tigris

Embarking on a Historical Adventure

‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ sets players in the heart of the Abbasid Caliphate, circa 830 AD. The game’s premise revolves around the Caliph’s quest to gather the world’s knowledge. Players increase their influence in the House of Wisdom, translating foreign scrolls into Arabic. This setting isn’t just a backdrop; it’s the soul of the game, immersing players in a historically rich environment.

Deep, Strategic Gameplay

The gameplay mechanics in ‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ are a testament to Garphill Games’ commitment to depth and strategy. Players will find familiar elements from its predecessor, yet the game stands distinct with its focused approach. The transition from dice building to bag building, alongside a more streamlined “point salad” nature, offers a new flavor of challenges. Every action, from recruiting translators to translating scrolls, is a careful step in a strategic dance.

Innovative Mechanics and Unique Challenges

The game innovates with its bag-building mechanic. Starting with basic resources and gradually acquiring more potent tools mirrors the process of scholarly advancement. The game’s focus on translating scrolls involves strategic planning and resource management, making each decision crucial. The blend of historical theme and engaging mechanics creates an experience that is both educational and entertaining.

Component Quality and Design

True to Garphill Games’ reputation, the components in ‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ are of good quality. The dice, meeples, and cards are well-crafted, although the cards do have a tendency to bend. This minor issue aside, the game’s components add to the overall enjoyment. The insert, while more functional than previous games, could have been more thoughtfully designed, yet it doesn’t detract from the overall experience.

Solo Play Excellence

The solo mode in ‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ deserves special attention. It offers a challenging and engaging experience that feels akin to playing against a real opponent. This mode is a significant improvement over previous iterations, providing solo gamers with a fulfilling and competitive gameplay experience.

Replayability and Varied Strategies

This game offers a wealth of replayability. With varied starting conditions and dynamic objectives, no two games feel the same. While the game has fewer strategic paths compared to a typical “point salad” game, the gameplay is so enjoyable that this becomes a minor point. The variance in scrolls and translator abilities ensures that each game will require a different approach, keeping the game fresh and exciting.


In conclusion, ‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ is a remarkable achievement in board gaming. It successfully combines a rich historical theme with challenging and innovative gameplay. The game is perfect for those who appreciate a deep, strategic experience. While it may be daunting for casual gamers, it’s an absolute joy for enthusiasts of history-themed games and complex strategies. ‘Scholars of the South Tigris’ is not just a game; it’s a journey through the Golden Age of the Abbasid Caliphate, offering a window into a world of knowledge and discovery. It stands as a testament to the power of board games to educate, challenge, and entertain. – David

Scratches: 8.5/10.0

Other reviews:

Go to Top